In the summer of 2008, someone dug up a beach at Coral Spring in Jamaica and drove it away in dump trucks.
Between May and July 2008, thieves with heavy excavators stripped the white sand from roughly 400 meters of shoreline at Coral Spring, in the parish of Trelawny on Jamaica’s north coast, and hauled it off at night. The beach belonged to Felicitas Limited, which had bought the 64-acre seafront property for a luxury villa resort. The diggers left deep trenches, mud and bare limestone where the sand had been. Investigators came to believe the sand had been sold to hotels building up their own beaches, yet no one was ever convicted of taking it.
Police and press estimates put the haul at about 500 truckloads, while coverage of the 2011 civil trial said about 250, and the developer’s claim described it as 6,000 cubic yards of sand. Five men were eventually charged with conspiracy and larceny, but the prosecution was abandoned in February 2011 after its main witness refused to testify. A civil suit for more than US$8 million against two hotel operators and a mining company went to trial in July 2011.
A Resort Site on the Trelawny Coast
Felicitas bought the Coral Spring property in August 2006 for US$2.4 million, and the company’s plans grew into a development valued at J$8 billion. The first phase was to include 36 luxury villas, a spa, a restaurant, an amphitheater and a marina, all built around the stretch of powdery white sand that gave the site its value. The beach sat at the end of a rough dirt road that ran past grazing goats and through a mangrove forest, far enough from the main road that work there could go unnoticed.
Kingston attorney Michael Hylton, whose clients included the Bob Marley family, was hired by the owners to find out where the sand had gone. At the site he found trenches cut deep into the shore, and he later told NPR’s Planet Money that some of the holes were about 10 feet deep. Witnesses had seen trucks moving sand during the night, but nobody had seen where the trucks went.
The scale of the job pointed to an organized operation, since excavators had to dig the trenches and a steady line of trucks had to carry the sand along the dirt road. Mark Shields, Jamaica’s deputy commissioner of police for crime, called it a very complex investigation in October 2008. He said there was “some suspicion that some police were in collusion with the movers of the sand.”
Jamaican law already treated the theft as a serious matter, because the Quarries Control Act of 1984 classes sea sand as quarry material that can only be dug under a ministerial license. Prime Minister Bruce Golding ordered a probe, and Daryl Vaz, a minister in the Office of the Prime Minister, became the government’s point person on the case. The opposition People’s National Party accused the government of a cover-up, while the developers suspended work on the resort and commissioned a study of the damage to nearby saltpans, mangroves and limestone forest.
Tracing Stolen Sand by Helicopter
Hylton reasoned that hundreds of truckloads were too much to hide in a warehouse or a single pile, so the sand had most likely been spread across a beach. Beachfront resorts were the obvious buyers, since they had both the money and the motive to lay new white sand along their shorelines. The investigators therefore went looking for beaches that had changed.
One of the owners went up in a helicopter with a sand scientist and a justice of the peace, whose job was to witness the flight and make sure nobody tampered with the evidence. From the air they spotted two hotels where stretches of brown or thin sand gave way to large expanses of fresh white sand. The helicopter landed at the edge of one resort long enough for the scientist to run out, scoop up samples and return.
Proving a match took longer than finding a suspect beach, because sand from different shores has to be compared grain by grain. Hylton hired sedimentologists and marine geologists to study grain size and mineral makeup, while the police served warrants on hotels to collect samples of their own. The resorts raked their beaches every night in the small hours, which churned old and new sand together. To get around that, the experts also compared the pebbles mixed in with the sand.
By August 2008, the National Environment and Planning Agency had tests run through the government’s Mines and Geology Division. They concluded that some of the stolen sand had been delivered to two hotel developments on the north coast. One of the hotel operators had already reported the delivery to the agency and the police when its contractor couldn’t produce a sand-mining permit. Government geologist Basil Young warned that the developers might have to wait around a century for nature to replace the beach.
Read next
Owen Baggett’s Pistol Shots at a Japanese Fighter Over Burma
Five Men Charged and a Witness Who Wouldn’t Testify
The criminal case moved slowly through the courts after three men were arrested and charged in 2008. In February 2009, Bedrock Building and Aggregates Limited, a Kingston mining and aggregates company, was charged in connection with the theft. Its principal owners, Christopher Pryce and Devon Sterling, were charged with conspiracy, larceny and breaches of the Quarries Control Act. That hearing was adjourned because some statements from the investigating officer and the laboratory test results hadn’t yet reached the court.
When the five accused appeared before the Falmouth Resident Magistrate’s Court on February 8, 2011, the prosecution told the court that the Crown couldn’t proceed. Its main witness had received threats and refused to give evidence, so the charges against all five men were dropped.
Felicitas had also gone to the Supreme Court in 2008, suing Fiesta Jamaica Limited, Riu Jamaicotel Limited, the owners of the Palmyra Resort and Spa, and Bedrock for more than US$8 million. The company argued that Bedrock had removed the sand and that the hotels should have known it was stolen, and the claim against Palmyra was later discontinued. When the trial opened in July 2011, managing director Fredrik Moe presented video of white marine sand on a beach that was otherwise mostly brown. Other footage showed workers spreading white sand on another hotel’s beach.
Fiesta told the court it had contracted Bedrock for marine sand in April 2008, believing the sand was legally obtained. Riu said its beach material had come from excavations on its own site that were finished in 2007. Bedrock denied taking any sand from Coral Spring.
Why a Beach Is Worth Stealing
The Coral Spring theft came to light at the moment when scientists were starting to measure how much sand the world consumes. Pascal Peduzzi, a Swiss researcher with the United Nations Environment Programme, was working in Jamaica at the time and heard villagers describe armed men arriving with trucks to carry away their beach. He went on to publish a UN report titled Sand, Rarer Than One Thinks, and he later directed the agency’s GRID-Geneva center.
In April 2022, a UNEP report estimated that the world uses 50 billion tonnes of sand and gravel each year, enough to build a wall 27 meters wide and 27 meters high around the planet. That makes sand the most used resource on Earth after water, and its main use is in concrete and glass. Much of the planet’s desert sand is too smooth and rounded to bind well in concrete, so builders depend on the angular grains found in riverbeds, on seabeds and on beaches.
Years after the case ended, Planet Money host Sarah Gonzalez visited one of the resorts accused of buying the stolen sand and found a wide white beach lined with bars and pools. Everyone she spoke to told her that whatever sand the hotel had received in 2008 was long gone, and that she was probably standing on a newer batch brought in from some other beach.




