DVD Jon: The Norwegian Teen Charged for Playing His Own DVDs

In January 2000 Norwegian police took two computers from the home of a 16-year-old programmer and questioned him for nearly seven hours about software he had written to watch films he already owned.

The teenager was Jon Lech Johansen, and the software was DeCSS, a program released in late 1999 that removed the Content Scrambling System, the encryption that stopped DVDs from playing on unlicensed equipment. Johansen had helped write it at 15 because his computer ran Linux, and no licensed DVD player existed for it. After a complaint from the Motion Picture Association and the DVD Copy Control Association, Norwegian prosecutors charged him with a form of data break-in.

Two Norwegian courts acquitted him, the Oslo district court in January 2003 and the Borgarting Court of Appeal in December 2003. Both found that a person who buys a DVD legally has the right to watch it, including on equipment the film studios never approved. By the time the case ended, the Norwegian press had given him the nickname DVD Jon.

The DeCSS case

Program releasedLate 1999
Age when written15
Police raidJanuary 2000
First acquittalJanuary 7, 2003, Oslo
Appeal acquittalDecember 22, 2003
Prosecution endedJanuary 5, 2004

A Lock on Every DVD

The Content Scrambling System was the copy protection on commercial DVDs, licensed to player manufacturers by the DVD Copy Control Association. A disc would only play on hardware or software that held a license, and in 1999 nobody had licensed a player for Linux, the free operating system Johansen used.

The silver underside of a DVD with rainbow reflections across its surface.
The playing side of a commercial DVD, the kind of disc the Content Scrambling System was built to protect. Photo: public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Johansen was a co-founder of a small group of programmers called Masters of Reverse Engineering, or MoRE. Two other members, whom he knew only by their screen names, worked with him on DeCSS. He later said that the decryption code came from someone in Germany, and that his own part was the graphical interface that made the program usable.

He posted DeCSS online so that other programmers could test it, and it spread quickly. He said he used it to watch his own films on his Linux computer, instead of buying a separate DVD player. The film industry’s complaint described it as a program that encouraged DVD piracy.

The Raid and the Charges

The Motion Picture Association and the DVD Copy Control Association filed their complaint with Okokrim, the Norwegian unit for economic crime, in January 2000. The industry asked for a criminal investigation of Johansen and of his father, Per, who owned the computer on which DeCSS had first been posted, although Per was never charged. The industry also asked for a charge of contributory copyright infringement, which Okokrim chose not to bring against Jon.

Police searched the house that month and took away the computers, the phone and the disks. Johansen was taken to a police station for questioning and then released, and the case moved slowly through the prosecutors’ office for the next two years.

On January 9, 2002, when Johansen had just turned 18, Okokrim indicted him under section 145(2) of the Norwegian criminal code. That section made it a crime to break a protective device in order to obtain data unlawfully, and it carried a sentence of up to two years in prison.

His lawyer, Halvor Manshaus, summed up the problem with the charge. Johansen, he said, “is charged with breaking a code and accessing the data that he is allowed to access.” The Electronic Frontier Foundation, an American digital rights group, helped with his defense.

Read next
Dutch Startup Created Concrete Designed to Grow Moss

Was DVD Jon convicted?

The Oslo court acquitted Johansen on January 7, 2003, after a trial that opened on December 9, 2002, at which he pleaded not guilty. Prosecutors had also accused him of helping others make illegal copies by putting the program online. They asked for a 90-day suspended jail sentence, the confiscation of his computer equipment and payment of the court costs.

The pale stone front of a large modern courthouse with a wooden entrance door and a balcony above it.
The Oslo courthouse, Oslo Tinghus, photographed in 2022. Photo: Ssu, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The court sat as a panel of three, one judge and two technology experts, and its ruling was unanimous and ran to 25 pages. The head judge, Irene Sogn, found no evidence that Johansen or anyone else had used DeCSS to watch pirated films. The court held that he could not be convicted of breaking into his own property.

The ruling said that a person who buys a legally produced DVD has legal access to the film. That right holds “even if the films are played in a different way than the makers had foreseen,” and all three of the prosecution’s requests were rejected.

Johansen, who was 19, said, “I’m very satisfied. We won support on all points.” He had expected to win, he added, though “it can go either way,” and he said the case was about the rights of consumers, which copyright holders around the world were trying to limit. He also expected another round in court, because it was the first case of its kind in Norway.

The prosecutors had two weeks to decide whether to appeal, and the Motion Picture Association said it would study the decision in detail.

The Appeal and the Second Acquittal

His expectation proved correct within two weeks, when Okokrim filed an appeal on January 20, 2003, and the Borgarting Court of Appeal agreed to hear the case. The second trial began in Oslo on December 2, 2003, before a panel of seven led by Judge Wenche Skjeggestad.

The appeal court ruled on December 22, 2003, earlier than expected, and again acquitted him on all counts. It found that he had used the code only to watch DVDs he owned, and that prosecutors had not shown DeCSS being used for copyright infringement. The court accepted that the program could be used to make illegal copies, but it found that this had never been his aim, and it held that Norwegians could make personal copies of discs they had bought. The court noted that discs are easily damaged, which gave buyers a reason to keep backups.

Prosecutors had asked this time for a suspended jail term and a fine of 20,000 Norwegian kroner. Johansen, then 20, was on holiday in France when the verdict came, and Manshaus could not reach him with the news. The lawyer said that two acquittals within a year should be enough to close the case, and the prosecutor, Inge Marie Sunde, called a further appeal “a matter worth evaluating.”

The Motion Picture Association of America called him a “serial hacker” and urged the Norwegian parliament to “move quickly” to change the law. On January 5, 2004, Okokrim announced that it would not take the case to the Supreme Court. Its decision left in place a ruling that a Norwegian who buys a DVD may play it on any equipment. That included a Linux computer like the one police had carried out of Johansen’s home four years earlier.

More from Terribly Interesting

Sources