Koko the Gorilla, Her Kitten All Ball and the Toy Cat She Refused

On Christmas morning in 1983, a gorilla named Koko unwrapped a toy cat made of cement, vinyl and black velvet and began charging angrily up and down her room.

Koko had been taught to communicate in American Sign Language by the developmental psychologist Francine “Penny” Patterson, and for months she had been signing that she wanted a cat. Patterson realized from the outburst that the toy was the problem and that Koko wanted a living animal. Almost six months later, in 1984, Koko was allowed to choose from a litter of three kittens, and she picked a tailless gray tabby that she named All Ball. He lived at the Gorilla Foundation in Woodside, California, for about half a year until he got out, ran into traffic and was killed by a car in December 1984.

Everything known about what Koko meant comes from her caregivers’ reading of her signs, and critics have long questioned whether she understood them.

A Birthday Request in Sign Language

Koko was born at the San Francisco Zoo on the Fourth of July, 1971, Patterson met her at the zoo in 1972, when Koko was a year old.

Patterson held a party for Koko every birthday, with cake, sparkling apple cider and presents. Three days before one of those parties she asked Koko what she wanted. After first signing for cereal and something good to drink, Koko answered “Cat,” and later repeated “Cat, cat, cat.” The request made sense to Patterson, who knew that two of Koko’s favorite stories were “Puss in Boots” and “The Three Little Kittens.”

Patterson did not want to give her a stuffed cat, because she knew Koko would eventually tear it apart. The only durable toy she could find was in a mail order catalog, a cat made of cement and covered with vinyl and black velvet. She chose it because it looked real and seemed gorilla-proof, but it arrived too late for the birthday, so she saved it for Christmas. In December she showed Koko a booklet of about twenty drawings of possible presents, and Koko pointed to a doll, some nuts and a cat.

The Velvet Cat and the Litter Raised by a Terrier

On Christmas morning Koko threw aside the nuts in her stocking and signed “That stink” at the new doll. At the velvet cat she signed “That red,” the word she often used for anger, and then ran back and forth banging on the walls in display charges. Later that day a friend named Barbara, who had known Koko since she was a baby, asked to see the toy. Koko pulled a blanket over her head, covered the cat with a rag and handed Barbara a toy dinosaur instead.

Almost six months later one of Patterson’s assistants, Karen, arrived with three kittens that had been abandoned by their mother and raised by a Cairn terrier. Koko signed “Love that” and gave each kitten her blow test, blowing into its face the way she greeted every new acquaintance. The first was smoky gray and white, the second a tailless gray tabby and the third a brown tabby. When the staff asked which one she wanted, she pointed to the tailless tabby.

Patterson never asked Koko why she chose him and guessed it might be because, like a gorilla, he had no tail. Two days later the kittens visited again, and Koko carried the tabby on her thigh and then on the back of her neck, the way gorilla mothers carry their young. She signed “Baby,” and when asked what she would call him, she signed “All Ball.” By the end of that week the kitten had become a permanent member of the household.

Read next
An Elephant’s Trunk Has No Bones and About 90,000 Muscles

Life With All Ball

For the first few weeks All Ball lived in Patterson’s house. Every evening at six o’clock she carried him in her pocket to Koko’s trailer while she got the gorilla ready for bed. When he was older he slipped into the trailer on his own, which worried Patterson at first, but Koko was always gentle with him and he was never afraid of her.

He was an aggressive cat who bit people for no reason, possibly because his mother had abandoned him at birth, and he bit Koko as well. She signed “Cat bite. Obnoxious,” yet she never struck back. She combed and petted him and checked his eyes, ears and mouth, which is how she came to discover his ear mites. Patterson once posed him on an orange towel with a green toy and asked Koko to paint him. From ten colors Koko chose black for his body, orange for the towel, green for the toy and tan for his eyes.

What Happened to Koko’s Kitten?

On a foggy morning in December 1984, an assistant told Patterson that All Ball had been hit by a car and had died instantly. Patterson went to Koko at once and told her that Ball had been hit by a car and that she would not see him again. Koko gave no response, so Patterson left the trailer, and ten minutes later she heard Koko’s distress call, a loud, long series of high-pitched hoots.

A brown and gray striped cat with no tail standing on a sofa and looking at the camera.
A tailless Manx tabby, the same breed as All Ball and the kind Koko’s caregivers searched for after he died. Photo: Michelle Weigold, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Three days later Patterson asked Koko about her kitten, and Koko signed “Cry,” then “Blind,” and then “Sleep cat.” A few weeks after that, Koko saw a picture of a gray tabby that looked very much like All Ball, pointed to it and signed “Cry, sad, frown.”

Thousands of letters reached the foundation, many from children, and nearly all of them said Koko should have a new kitten. When Barbara asked Koko on December 20 what she wanted for Christmas, she signed “Cat cat tiger cat.” In January, shown a picture of three kittens with long, short and missing tails, she again pointed to the one with no tail. The Humane Society had no kittens, and a pregnant Manx turned out only to be putting on weight. For weeks, whenever someone asked Koko where her cat was, she looked around as if she were searching for Ball.

A Manx breeder finally traced a litter in Southern California, and on March 24, 1985, a red, tiger-striped Manx kitten was brought to her. Koko purred, laid him on her chest and petted him, and when Patterson asked to hold the new kitten, Koko kissed and cradled him and would not let him go.

More from Terribly Interesting

Sources