The Day Ethiopia Destroyed an Invading Italian Army at Adwa

On March 1, 1896, near the town of Adwa in northern Ethiopia, the army of Emperor Menelik II destroyed an invading Italian force in a single day of fighting, and eight days later Italy’s prime minister resigned.

By the 1890s European powers had divided most of Africa between them. Italy, which already held the Red Sea colony of Eritrea, meant to add Ethiopia by claiming it as a protectorate under a treaty the two countries had signed in 1889. Menelik rejected that reading of the treaty, and when Italian troops pushed south into the Ethiopian province of Tigray he raised an army that historians estimate at between 73,000 and more than 100,000 men. Most of them carried modern rifles bought from European suppliers including France and Russia. The Italian force that attacked him numbered somewhere between 14,519 and 17,770 combat troops, depending on the historian.

The result forced Italy to sign a peace treaty recognizing Ethiopia as an independent state. France and Britain, which also had colonies on Ethiopia’s borders, signed treaties treating it as an equal the following year. By the end of the 19th century Ethiopia was one of very few independent countries left in Africa, and the only one that owed its independence to a victory on the battlefield.

Article 17 and the Treaty of Wuchale

Menelik, then acting as emperor, and Count Pietro Antonelli signed the Treaty of Wuchale on May 2, 1889, in the small town of Wuchale. In it Italy’s occupation of Eritrea was accepted in return for promises of financial and military help. The treaty had twenty articles, written in Amharic and Italian, and the two versions of Article 17 did not say the same thing. The Amharic text said the Ethiopian emperor could use the Italian government for his dealings with other powers. The Italian text said he was obliged to, which under the diplomatic conventions of the day made Ethiopia an Italian protectorate.

Italy acted on its own version almost at once, informing the European governments in October 1889 that Ethiopia was now its protectorate and that they could no longer deal with it directly. Every European power accepted the claim except the Ottoman Empire, which still claimed Eritrea, and Russia, which disliked the idea of an Orthodox Christian nation being placed under a Roman Catholic one. Italian diplomats maintained that the original Amharic text had contained the obligation and that Menelik had knowingly signed a changed copy. Menelik concluded that he had been deceived and formally denounced the treaty in the early 1890s.

Between 1890 and 1896 Italy pursued Ethiopia along two tracks at once. Its foreign ministry tried to persuade Menelik to accept the Italian reading and pressed other European governments to lean on him. Meanwhile the colonial ministry and the government of Eritrea worked to exploit resentment in Tigray against the new emperor from the southern province of Shewa, hoping to break the country apart. Both efforts failed, and in June 1894 even the leading figures of Tigray, Ras Mengesha Yohannes and Ras Alula, traveled to Menelik’s capital, Addis Ababa, to pay him homage.

How Menelik Armed and United Ethiopia

Menelik had been buying weapons long before the dispute with Italy began. As ruler of Shewa from 1878, he dealt directly with European diplomats and traders. The Swiss engineer Alfred Ilg, who arrived in 1879 and stayed for 29 years, became his most trusted foreign adviser on technical matters and on relations with Europe. France and Italy were both among the countries that supplied modern weapons to Shewa. The weapons were paid for with revenue from ivory, coffee and gold and from taxes on a slave trade run by merchants in the territories Menelik conquered to the south.

By 1895 his soldiers had thousands of modern rifles and quick-firing Hotchkiss guns with ammunition, and Menelik had seen to it that his infantry and gunners were trained to use them. On September 17, 1895, he issued a formal call to arms to the whole country. It declared that an enemy had come across the sea and broken through Ethiopia’s frontiers, and ordered every man with sufficient strength to follow him. The Italian commander, General Oreste Baratieri, predicted that Menelik could field only 30,000 men.

The Italians had already won early fights in the border region, crushing a rebellion led by Bahta Hagos in December 1894 and defeating Ras Mengesha at the Battle of Coatit in January 1895. On December 7, 1895, however, Ras Makonnen and Ras Mengesha overwhelmed a small Italian unit at Amba Alagi. Makonnen then besieged the Italian fort at Mekele until its commander, Major Giuseppe Galliano, surrendered on January 19, 1896, after the defenders had lost their water supply. Menelik let Galliano’s men march out and go free, saying his quarrel was with the government of Prime Minister Francesco Crispi, which undercut Crispi’s propaganda about Ethiopian cruelty to prisoners.

Read next
Jim Irvine’s Lockdown Walk and Britain’s Roman Trojan War Mosaic

The Night March and the Collapse of Three Brigades

By late February 1896 both armies were short of food, and Baratieri knew he was about to be replaced as governor. He told his four brigade commanders on the evening of February 29 that their provisions would run out in less than five days and suggested a retreat. His generals argued for an attack, and one of them, Vittorio Dabormida, said Italy would prefer the loss of two or three thousand men to a dishonorable retreat. Baratieri gave the order, and shortly after midnight three brigades set out to march in parallel to three mountain crests, with a fourth behind them in reserve.

The plan depended on General Matteo Albertone’s brigade taking a pass called Kidane Mehret, but Italian maps drawn from local descriptions confused it with a second place of a similar name farther west. Albertone followed his guides several miles beyond the rest of the army. His Eritrean troops held out for more than two hours. Menelik, who had been praying at the Church of St. George when the fighting began, considered pulling back after heavy losses. Empress Taytu Betul and Ras Mengesha then persuaded him to commit a reserve of 25,000 men. By 8:30 in the morning Albertone’s brigade was retreating, and Albertone himself was taken prisoner after his mule was shot.

The Ethiopian columns then turned on General Giuseppe Arimondi’s brigade in the center, outflanked it on both sides and broke it at around noon, and Arimondi was killed. Dabormida, trying to help Albertone, had led his brigade into the valley of Mariam Shewito, away from the rest of the army. There Ras Makonnen’s troops cut it off and surrounded it, and Dabormida disappeared during the final fighting. The Italians left behind all their artillery, 11,000 rifles and most of their transport as they fled toward Eritrea.

Estimates of the Italian dead run from about 5,900 to 6,133, including roughly 2,000 Eritrean colonial soldiers known as askaris, and about 3,800 men were taken prisoner. Ethiopian losses were estimated at between 3,886 and 7,000 killed. Around 800 captured askaris, regarded by the Ethiopians as traitors, had their right hands and left feet cut off. Italian prisoners were generally treated better, and Albertone was given a tent of his own, a horse and servants.

Riots in Italy, a Peace Treaty and Mussolini’s Revenge

The news set off street demonstrations in most major Italian cities, where universities and theaters in Rome were closed and crowds in Pavia blocked the railroad tracks to stop a troop train from leaving. King Umberto declared his birthday, March 14, a day of mourning. Menelik chose not to push on into Eritrea, since his army was short of food and weakened by disease and he feared a larger Italian expedition. He limited his central demand to the cancellation of the Treaty of Wuchale.

Italy agreed on August 23 to abandon the treaty unconditionally, and the Treaty of Addis Ababa, signed on October 26, 1896, returned the Italian prisoners. It also required Italy to pay 10 million lire for their upkeep and confirmed the independence Italy had already conceded. Italy kept most of the territory it held north of the Mareb River, the land that became the border between Eritrea and Ethiopia. The Haitian journalist and diplomat Benito Sylvain, an early organizer of the Pan-African movement, went to Ethiopia after the victory. He became an aide-de-camp to Menelik in 1897 and represented both Ethiopia and Haiti at the 1900 Pan-African Conference in London.

Italy returned in force almost four decades later, when Benito Mussolini’s army crossed the Mareb River from Eritrea without a declaration of war on October 3, 1935, with about 200,000 soldiers. The invaders took Adwa on October 6, Mussolini’s air force dropped hundreds of tons of mustard gas on soldiers and civilians, and Italian troops entered Addis Ababa in May 1936. Italy occupied Ethiopia until 1941, when British Empire forces and Ethiopian guerrillas drove it out.

Every March 1 Ethiopia closes its schools, banks and government offices for Adwa Victory Day. In Addis Ababa crowds dressed as the patriots of 1896 gather at Menelik Square carrying portraits of Menelik II and Empress Taytu Betul.

More from Terribly Interesting

Sources